free shipping on orders over $95

Compare & Share February 2024 - Mystery Cigars

No reviews yet Write a Review
  • Free Shipping

  • Ship Worldwide

  • Safe Payments

  • Top Rated

We've added cigars to our monthly Compare & Share!

Compare & Share was conceived in brainstorming new ways to engage with the communal side of pipe smoking, and now we hope to do the same with cigars.

For $18.99, you'll receive 2 premium cigars—the Mystery Cigars will be the same for anyone who orders in that month. We will have removed the bands so that they remain a mystery until the end of the month, when we'll reveal the identity of the Mystery Cigars and Blends before listing next month's.

[note: the $18.99 price will always be a deal to some degree compared to the retail price of the two cigars.]

Our hope is that while trying these cigars and/or pipe tobacco blends, all who are taking part can discuss their thoughts, analyses, impressions, etc. You can join us on our Facebook Compare & Share group!

We think this could be a fun way to bring together two tenets that—for many—are at the core of premium tobacco: exploration and community. If you'd like to know more, check out our blog introducing Compare & Share!


Past Mystery Cigars:


December 2023

  1. CAO MoonTrance Corona
  2. Oliva Cuba Aliados Cab by EPC

November 2023

  1. H. Upmann 1844 Reserve Churchill
  2. Montecristo White Label Toro

October 2023

  1. Espinosa Laranja Azuelo Robusto
  2. ACE Prime Mas Ingneus Toro

September 2023

  1. Drunk Chicken DCO Gordo
  2. Tatuaje Nuevitas Jibaro #1

August 2023

  1. Eighty5 El Patron Laguito 6
  2. La Aurora Barrel Aged Robusto

July 2023

  1. Drew Estate Herrera Esteli Norento Toro Especial
  2. My Father The Judge Toro

June 2023

  1. Patina Habano Bronze
  2. Romeo Y Julieta Reserva Real Gran Toro

May 2023

  1. LCA El Septimo Zaya Nueva Reserva Robusto
  2. Serie O Maduro Robusto

April 2023

  1. Casa Current 1880 Oscuro Perfecto
  2. AJ Fernandez New World Oscuro

March 2023

  1. Cobblestone Classic Maduro Grande
  2. Plasencia Alma Fuerte Nestor IV Toro